Elden Ring Nightreign's Relic RNG Is a Painful Lesson in Loot Design
Elden Ring Nightreign's RNG relic system breeds helpless grind, undercutting an otherwise brilliant game.
I've just finished another flawless Elden Ring Nightreign run. My team and I breezed through the Nightlord, barely a death between us, seven flasks still in our pockets, and a level 15 character with weapons perfectly tuned to the boss's weakness. The victory screen appears, and I spam L1 with the rest of them, feeling like a god. Then the loot drops, and my heart sinks. Trash. Absolute trash.
One relic offers a damage boost with three greataxes, improved throwing knife damage, and fire pots in my inventory at the start of an expedition. It's a cruel joke. I sell it, take my murk to the merchant, and gamble again. More trash. This isn't a one-off; it's a pattern, and it's sucking the joy out of an otherwise brilliant game.

Let me be clear: I'm not writing off Elden Ring Nightreign. FromSoftware is clearly experimenting with new systems, and given how new the studio is to loot progression, I didn't expect perfection. But as an MMO veteran, I've seen this movie before. Pure RNG-dependent loot is a trap, and Nightreign has walked right into it.
The Titanforging Problem, Revisited
World of Warcraft once had a system called Titanforging. Any piece of gear could randomly upgrade to a higher item level, supposedly making lower-tier content feel rewarding. Instead, it made progression feel hollow. Players would kill a raid boss for the first time and disenchant half the loot because they already had better Warforged items from easier content. And the knowledge that any item could have been better left a lingering sense of disappointment. Blizzard eventually removed the system, admitting it made goals feel out of players' control.
Sound familiar? Swap a few nouns and that's exactly how I feel about Nightreign's relic system. Getting a new relic should be exciting, but I sell most of them. Even when I get one with two solid passives, I can't shake the thought that it could have had three. And none of it is within my control.
RNG Isn't the Enemy—Helplessness Is
I'm not against RNG. Diablo 4 is built on it, and I've sunk hundreds of hours into that game. The difference is that Diablo 4 gives you levers to pull. You can socket gems, temper gear to adjust affixes, or masterwork items to improve them. You still chase god rolls, but you can turn a mediocre drop into a usable upgrade along the way. That sense of incremental progress keeps you hooked.
Other games have learned this lesson too. Darktide launched with roll-dependent loot that quickly became frustrating, but after two years of feedback, Fatshark reworked it. Path of Exile 2 is currently taking heat for making loot feel unrewarding. Every game with crushing RNG eventually shifts toward player control—whether through tokens, badges, or systems that let you convert bad luck into progress.
| Game | RNG System | Player Control Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| WoW (old) | Titanforging | None—pure random upgrades |
| Diablo 4 | Affix rolls | Tempering, masterworking, gem socketing |
| Darktide | Roll-dependent loot | Rerolls, crafting rework |
| Nightreign | Relic drops | None—pure slot machine |
That last row is the problem. Nightreign's relic system is a slot machine with no pity timer, no crafting, and no way to nudge the odds. You grind, you gamble, and you walk away empty-handed.
What Nightreign Could Steal (Politely)
I don't want a battle pass or a live-service roadmap. I just want a few smart systems that respect my time. Here's what I'd borrow from other games:
-
Relic recycling with a twist. Let me break down a relic and have a chance to extract one of its passives, then apply that passive to another relic for a hefty murk cost. Make it expensive—this is endgame build-tuning, after all—but give me a clear goal to work toward.
-
Colour swapping. If I have a relic with great passives that don't fit my current urn, let me pay a steep murk fee to change its colour. 20,000 Limveld bucks? Fine. At least I'm not stuck praying to the RNG gods.
-
A pity system for passives. After a certain number of relics without a third passive, guarantee one. Or let me trade in a stack of junk relics for a random high-tier one. Anything to break the endless gamba limbo.
These changes wouldn't remove the thrill of rolling a perfect relic—that moment would still save you a massive time sink—but they'd stop entire runs from feeling like wasted effort.

A Mountain, Not Purgatory
I want to build the perfect Executor now that I've slain all the Nightlords. But to do that, I'm facing an potentially endless session at the merchant's jar bazaar slot machine. I'm not afraid of a grind—I've played MMOs for years. What I'm afraid of is perpetual gamba limbo. One is a mountain to climb; the other is purgatory. Nightreign doesn't have to choose the latter.
FromSoftware has crafted a combat experience that's exhilarating, chaotic, and deeply rewarding. It would be a shame if the loot system undermined all that goodwill. The studio is new to this genre, but the lessons are out there, written in the angry forum posts of a thousand players before them. All it takes is a willingness to look at what worked—and what didn't—in the games that came before.
I'll keep playing Nightreign. The core loop is too good to abandon. But every time I sell another trash relic, I'll be hoping that FromSoftware is taking notes. Because a little RNG keeps things lively, but pure RNG-dependent loot? That's just a trash fire waiting to happen. 🔥